Help stabilising mini-gmp
Torbjörn Granlund
tg at gmplib.org
Mon Nov 14 14:49:12 UTC 2016
I recently enabled automated testing of mini-gmp, the little
library-in-the-library which comes with GMP. It has thus far discovered
these problems:
1. GMP_CHECK_RANDOMIZE is not always printed for failing tests. This
makes it hard to reproduce intermittent failures. It needs to be
printed earlier, and/or a buffer needs flushing.
2. There are inexplicable timeouts (or possibly excessive memory use)
triggered by t-pprime_p for some of our systems:
armel.sys.gmplib.org-dyn:32, g5.gmplib.org-dyn:32,
m68k.sys.gmplib.org-m68040-stat:standard,
m68k.sys.gmplib.org-m68040-dyn:standard.
Perhaps the test is simply too slow, or its time varies hugely, or it
hits an infinite loop.
3. The mini-gmp check target fails when the main build does not use the
compiler default ABI. This affects:
hannahsol32.gmplib.org-dyn:32
hannahsol32.gmplib.org-dyn-fat:32
shell.gmplib.org-dyn-clang36-clang++36-fat:32
shell.gmplib.org-dyn-clang36-clang++36:32
shell.gmplib.org-dyn-clang35-clang++35-fat:32
shell.gmplib.org-dyn-clang35-clang++35:32
shell.gmplib.org-dyn-clang34-clang++34-fat:32
shell.gmplib.org-dyn-clang34-clang++34:32
shell.gmplib.org-dyn-clang33-clang++33-fat:32
shell.gmplib.org-dyn-clang33-clang++33:32
One may wonder why not more configs are affected!
4. There are failures with t-str, this affects
olympic.gmplib.org-dyn:64, olympic.gmplib.org-stat:64,
olympic.gmplib.org:64.
5. The t-div test intermittently fails on at least
sky.gmplib.org-k10-dyn-clang-3.6-clang++-3.6:64 (note that it uses
clang, which means the likelihood of a compiler bug being the culprit
is perhaps high).
6. The t-limbs test triggers an assert. It looks like any config could
trigger this, but thus far it has only happened on
shell.gmplib.org-dyn-gcc49-g++49:64, ivydeb32v7.gmplib.org-stat-fat:32.
7. On alpha, t-cmp_d fails:
dupont.gmplib.org-alphaev4-dyn:standard,
dupont.gmplib.org-alphaev4-stat:standard
dupont.gmplib.org-alphaev5-dyn:standard
dupont.gmplib.org-alphaev5-stat:standard
dupont.gmplib.org-dyn:standard
dupont.gmplib.org-stat:standard
8. There are what looks like genuine arithmetic problems triggered by
t-gcd. But since the only example is
shell.gmplib.org-stat-clang35-clang++35-fat:32 which uses clang, it
might also be a compiler bug.
I am busy with other GMP projects in this period, and the main mini-gmp
maintainer is busy at work. If you have time and skill, please help us
address these problems!
--
Torbjörn
Please encrypt, key id 0xC8601622
More information about the gmp-devel
mailing list